Tuesday, September 30, 2014

Institution Breakdown

What happens when public institutions fail?


Fail to provide citizens with the services an institution was tasked with providing in the first place? Fail to establish a trustworthy service delivery and rule of law? Fail to provide its citizens with an environment of safety and sustainability? In the case of DC's Workers Compensation division, these failures could, and have, expose District residents to insufficient treatment, unlawful assessments, chronic debt and unemployment and in the hypothetical worst case scenarios, potential homelessness or even death.

It is estimated that the Workers Compensation Fund could be missing, depending on the source, anywhere from $20 million to $60 million. The Department's mismanagement and lack of clear leadership has left the system in such disarray that a person that had been disbarred by the Indiana Bar Association from practicing law in 1998 was some how allowed to sit on the bench as an appeals judge in the District for the past 16 years. That's right; a person deemed by another State as unfit to practice law due to a propensity to falsify documents and other "chronically deceptive behavior" was allowed by the DC Department of Employment Services to sit on the bench and deliver almost two decades of potentially incorrect and damaging decisions. The amount of people, victims, employers and insurers effected by this "oversight" is close to immeasurable and it's true impact nearly insurmountable.

I became aware of this particularly ugly case of complete institutional deterioration via the work of a friend who represents a microcosm of those effected by its impact. I intend to track the progress of this saga and will be actively promoting its unraveling throughout visual storytelling. DC Council Member Vincent Orange played host to an initial hearing on the matter last Friday, so I stopped by to get a feel for things and capture a few moments of the hearing.






Washington City Paper appears to be the only news outlet paying this situation any attention (really, Washington Post??), and City Desk author Jeffrey Anderson was the first to break the story and has followed up with a number of additional pieces on the matter.